1*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# From: megaadm@rina.quantum.de
2*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# Subject: Bug report - closing down pipes which read from shell com
3*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# To: bug-gnu-utils@prep.ai.mit.edu
4*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# Date: Thu, 27 Feb 1997 23:19:16 +0100 (CET)
5*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# CC: arnold@gnu.ai.mit.edu
6*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#
7*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# Hello people,
8*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#
9*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# i think i found a bug or something mysterious behaviour in
10*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# gawk Version 3.0 patchlevel 0.
11*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#
12*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# I am running on linux 2.0.25 under bash.
13*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#
14*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# Could you please have a look at the following awk program
15*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# an let me please know, if this is what i expect it to,
16*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# namely a bug.
17*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#
18*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# ----------- cut here --------------------------------------------
19*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter MelloBEGIN	{
20*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			# OS is linux 2.0.25
21*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			# shell is bash
22*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			# Gnu Awk (gawk) 3.0, patchlevel 0
23*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			# The command i typed on the shell was "gawk -f <this_prog> -"
24*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
25*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			#com = "cal 01 1997"
26*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			com = ("cat pipeio2.in")
27*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
28*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			# Don't use empty lines, because Windows ECHO does
29*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			# something different when invoked without arguments
30*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			while ((com | getline fnam) > 0 && fnam != "") {
31*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
32*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#				com_tr = "echo " fnam " | tr [0-9]. ..........."
33*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#				com_tr = "echo " fnam " | sed 's/[0-9]/./g'"
34*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				com_tr = "echo " fnam " | sed \"s/[0-9]/./g\""
35*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				# print "\'" com_tr "\'"
36*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				print "'" com_tr "'"
37*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
38*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				com_tr | getline nam
39*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				print nam
40*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
41*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				# please run that program and take a look at the
42*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				# output. I think this is what was expected.
43*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
44*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				# Then comment in the following 4 lines and see
45*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				# what happens. I expect the first pipe "com | getline"
46*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				# not to be close, but i think this is exactly what happens
47*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				# So, is this ok ?
48*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
49*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				if (close(com_tr) < 0) {
50*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello					print ERRNO
51*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello					break
52*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello				}
53*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			}
54*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello
55*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello			close(com)
56*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello		}
57*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# ----------- cut here --------------------------------------------
58*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#
59*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# There is another thing i do not understand.
60*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# Why doesn't the awk - command "close" reports an
61*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# error, if i would say close("abc") which i had never
62*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# openend ?
63*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello#
64*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# Regards,
65*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# Ulrich Gvbel
66*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# --
67*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# /********************************************************\
68*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# *     Ulrich Gvbel, goebel@quantum.de                    *
69*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# *     Quantum Gesellschaft f|r Software mbH, Dortmund    *
70*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# *     phone  : +49-231-9749-201  fax: +49-231-9749-3     *
71*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# *     private: +49-231-803994    fax: +49-231-803994     *
72*3ee4fc2aSCody Peter Mello# \********************************************************/
73